Friday 28 September 2007

The Devil is an NHS accountant

Once the shock had subsided we set about researching my options. According to the literature my prognosis would be better if I had as much of the tumour excised as possible. After consultation with my oncologist I contacted the neurosurgeon who initially conducted the biopsy. He insisted that the risks far outweighed any possible benefits. Risks being paralysis or death. He added that it would be highly unlikely that I would find a neurosurgeon in this country who would perform such an operation. He certainly wasn’t going to make any attempt to open my head again.
So what was in store for me? I was to have a course of thirty radiotherapy sessions and hopefully a programme of oral chemotherapy called temozolamide, the current ‘gold standard’ chemotherapy treatment for malignant brain tumours.
It was reasoned that this combination would reduce the tumour's size and inhibit further growth. However, I soon discovered that those not so nice people (I’m trying to watch my manners here, what I really want to call them is unprintable) at NICE (National Institute for Health and Clinical Excellence) had taken away the possibility of chemotherapy. This is the organisation responsible for providing national guidance on promoting good health and preventing and treating ill health. In addition, NICE helps health professionals implement THEIR guidance by providing tools such as cost templates, audit criteria and slide sets (I've said enough already, wink! wink!). NICE produces guidance in three areas of health:

1. Public health - guidance on the promotion of good health and the prevention of ill health for those working in the NHS, local authorities and the wider public and voluntary sector
2. Health technologies - guidance on the use of new and existing medicines, treatments and procedures within the NHS
3. Clinical practice - guidance on the appropriate treatment and care of people with specific diseases and conditions within the NHS.


Basically, ‘bean counters’. The ones that decide if drugs are released, and if so to who. For example, this is an extract from an official release on their website;

Where first-line chemotherapy with PCV has failed, temozolomide should be compared with the only alternative, which is best supportive care. However, the only data compares the benefits of temozolomide with those of procarbazine alone. Costs per cycle of temozolomide are estimated to be £1,488 including hospital costs and medications for side effects.’ Estimating cost per quality adjusted life year (QALY) is difficult because the extension of median survival time is not statistically significant, and the quality of life data are limited. The main benefit of temozolomide is that a proportion of patients benefit from a longer progression free survival time. Therefore the most useful measure of cost-effectiveness is cost per progression free week. Costs will continue to accrue if patients remain progression free, because further cycles of the drug will be given until progression occurs.

As you can see the heartless bastards are obsessed with money and statistics, and would prefer to leave a patient to ‘rot’ in a hospital bed rather than give him or her a shot at beating the disease, or in the very least holding it back awhile.
And in their infinite wisdom NICE decided that temozolomide, "…within its licensed indications, was recommended as an option for the treatment of newly diagnosed glioblastoma multiforme (GBM) in patients with a World Health Organization (WHO) performance status of 0 or 1."

To explain this WHO performance status thing;

0: able to carry out all normal activity without restriction
1: restricted in strenuous activity but ambulatory and able to carry out light work
2:ambulatory and capable of all self-care but unable to carry out any work activities; up and about more than 50% of waking hours
3:symptomatic and in a chair or in bed for greater than 50% of the day but not bedridden
4:completely disabled; cannot carry out any self-care; totally confined to bed or chair.


First part was fine as I had a ‘newly diagnosed’ GBM. Unfortunately, due to the epilepsy it caused, I was off work. As a result I was loosely classified as a ‘2’. So I got the ‘big middle finger’ from the rigid rule worshiping ‘demi-god accountants’ when it came to my PCT (Primary Care Trust) at Richmond and Twickenham authorizing the use of temozolomide in my case. It appeared to me, and those around me, that the Health Service had given up half way through. Bullshit considering that in my job I pay around £2568 in National Insurance contributions, and £5072 minimum in tax every year. When added up and multiplied over a working life that’s a lot of cash to the government and Health Service, and I’m not even going to start mentioning that every time I put my warrant card in my pocket and walk out the door I’m willing to put my life on the line for the people of London. For goodness sake I tackled and arrested a robber armed with a screwdriver a few years ago, whilst off duty, and on my birthday. I earned that bloody drug!

2 comments:

Ed said...

That title hits the nail squarely on the head, feckers!
A most educational insight to how the NHS and NICE don't work.
Keep up the good work.
TTFN

The bastard child of Gene Hunt said...

Yes my friend, truly evil, look what they done to the late great Tony Wilson. In the end they held back the medication to fight his kidney cancer. The groups he helped get to the top, e.g. Happy Mondays, New Order, had to group together to help him. All that he done for Manchester and music meant nothing to that bean-counting scum.